From Informal to Formal: Unlocking the Potential of African SMEs

Hi, I’m Innocent—your guide in the world of African innovation and entrepreneurship. Lately, I’ve been reflecting on a critical challenge: while SMEs form the backbone of Africa’s economy—accounting for up to 95% of all businesses and contributing nearly 50% of GDP—most of these enterprises still operate in the informal sector. Today, we explore why transitioning from informal to formal isn’t merely about checking regulatory boxes, but about building a resilient foundation that can unlock growth, stability, and lasting impact. Drawing inspiration from Reflecting on 2024: Key Takeaways For the African Startup Ecosystem (au-startups.com), let’s dive deep into the informal economy’s realities and the transformative potential of formalization.

The Power and Pitfalls of the Informal Economy

Across Africa, the informal sector is both a symbol of resilience and a source of inherent limitations. Many SMEs thrive by operating outside the strict confines of government regulation—they’re agile, locally rooted, and often born out of necessity. However, this informality brings significant challenges: limited access to finance, lack of legal protection, and restricted market expansion. These constraints frequently trap businesses in a cycle where growth is stunted, despite the immense entrepreneurial potential.

Why Do So Many Businesses Remain Informal?
Several factors contribute to the persistence of informality among African SMEs:

• Cost and Complexity: Formalization can involve lengthy, bureaucratic procedures and significant costs that many small entrepreneurs cannot afford.

• Lack of Awareness: A considerable number of business owners are unaware of the long-term benefits that formalization can offer, such as increased access to funding and legal protections.

• Inadequate Infrastructure: In many regions, the absence of streamlined, digital registration systems makes the formalization process daunting and time-consuming.

Building a Foundation for the Future: The Case for Formalization

Transitioning to the formal economy means more than merely registering a business—it’s about laying the groundwork for sustainable success. Formal enterprises enjoy numerous benefits, including:

• Enhanced Access to Finance: Transparent records and verified financials help formal businesses attract banks and investors, easing access to loans, VC, and grants.

• Legal and Institutional Protection: Formal status provides a strong legal framework to enforce contracts and protect intellectual property, reducing risks and stabilizing operations.

• Market Expansion Opportunities: Registered companies can bid on government contracts and engage in international trade, boosting credibility and enabling scalable growth.

• Improved Business Practices: Formalization drives better record keeping and financial transparency, enhancing management and building stakeholder confidence for long-term success.

• Access to Government Incentives: Many governments offer tax breaks, subsidies, and special economic zones to formal businesses, fostering innovation and economic growth.

• Enhanced Corporate Governance and Risk Management: Formal businesses can implement best practices in management and accountability, which helps them better mitigate risks during economic challenges..

The main obstacles to formalization in sub-Saharan Africa

The main obstacles to formalization in sub-Saharan Africa include a combination of structural, financial, and regulatory challenges. These barriers are deeply rooted in the economic, institutional, and cultural landscape of the region. Key obstacles include:

1. High Costs and Bureaucratic Complexity: Registering a business often involves lengthy and expensive procedures, which deter many small enterprises from formalizing. Despite some improvements, such as streamlined processes in certain countries, the costs remain prohibitive for many entrepreneurs.The absence of simplified, digital registration systems in many regions makes the process time-consuming and daunting1.

2. Limited Awareness of Benefits: Many informal business owners lack awareness of the advantages of formalization, such as access to finance, legal protections, and market opportunities. This lack of understanding reduces the perceived value of transitioning to formality.

3. Cultural and Social Norms: In some cases, informal business practices are deeply embedded in local cultures and traditions. Entrepreneurs may prefer informal arrangements due to familiarity or community-based trust systems that bypass formal institutions

4. Tax Burdens Many informal businesses fear that formalization will lead to excessive tax liabilities without corresponding benefits like improved public services or infrastructure.

Addressing these obstacles requires targeted policy interventions, including simplifying registration processes, raising awareness about the benefits of formalization, improving access to finance, and strengthening institutional support systems.

How can governments improve the formalization process for SMEs

Governments can improve SME formalization by addressing systemic barriers through targeted policy reforms, streamlined processes, and incentives. Below are evidence-based strategies supported by global case studies and research:

1. Simplify Business Registration and Licensing

Digital platforms reduce bureaucratic delays. For example:

• Estonia’s e-Residency allows global entrepreneurs to register businesses online, accessing EU markets without physical presence1.

• Kenya’s digital registration portals cut registration time from months to days, enhancing transparency.
  One-stop shops and reduced fees (e.g., Thailand’s streamlined process) lower entry costs.

2. Streamline Tax Compliance

Simplified tax regimes improve adoption:

• Flat tax rates and e-filing (e.g., Estonia’s 98% electronic tax compliance) reduce administrative burdens.

• Presumptive taxation or monotax systems (merging taxes/social security into one payment) ease compliance for MSEs.
  Incentives like temporary tax breaks encourage formalization.

3. Strengthen Institutional Support

Capacity-building programs address gaps in financial literacy and business management:

• Training and mentorship (e.g., Colombia’s se formaliza program) raised awareness and formalized 40% of targeted SMEs.

• Public-private partnerships provide access to markets, finance, and technology.
  Digital tools (e.g., Turkey’s e-invoice systems) improve tax compliance and reduce evasion

4. Address Awareness and Cultural Barriers
Public campaigns and localized outreach dispel misconceptions about formalization:
Colombia’s awareness programs reached 80,000 entrepreneurs annually, emphasizing benefits like legal protections.
Community-based initiatives align formalization with cultural norms (e.g., cooperatives in Kenya).

7. Leverage Technology for Transparency
Digital audits and data analytics (e.g., Turkey’s e-audit systems) improve compliance without overburdening SMEs.
Regional trade agreements and cross-border digital platforms expand market access for formalized SMEs.

By combining these strategies, governments can create an enabling environment where formalization aligns with SMEs’ long-term growth and societal development goals

A case study in Kenya shows that the introduction of digital registration platforms has significantly reduced the time required to formalize a business—from months to just a few days. This streamlined process not only encourages more entrepreneurs to register their businesses but also enhances the overall transparency and efficiency of the economy.

Provoking Thought: Envisioning a Transformed Future

Imagine an Africa where every entrepreneur has the support to transition from informal to formal operations. Such a shift could unleash unprecedented economic growth, drive innovation, and fundamentally reshape societal structures. The ripple effects would be profound:

• Empowered Communities: Formal businesses are better positioned to reinvest in their communities, driving improvements in education, healthcare, and infrastructure.

• Inclusive Economic Growth: When SMEs operate formally, they contribute more effectively to national revenues, creating a virtuous cycle of growth and development.

• A Legacy of Innovation: A formalized business environment fosters a culture of accountability and innovation, ensuring that the entrepreneurial spirit of Africa continues to flourish for generations.

Publications such as Harvard Business Review and reports by the McKinsey Global Institute have underscored that increasing formalization among SMEs could boost GDP growth and create millions of new jobs, demonstrating that the benefits extend far beyond individual businesses.

Final Thoughts

The journey from informal to formal is more than a regulatory requirement—it’s a transformative process that unlocks sustainable growth, expands market opportunities, and fortifies economic stability. As African SMEs embrace formalization, they not only enhance their own prospects but also contribute to a more robust and inclusive economy. The path may be challenging, but the rewards are transformative and far-reaching.

Enjoyed this piece?
Stay updated on the latest insights and stories from the African startup ecosystem by subscribing to Startinev On The Go! Don’t miss out on deep dives, founder stories, and practical lessons for building successful, sustainable businesses.

Subscribe here